The full content of this document is only available to subscribing institutions. More information can be found via www.amdigital.co.uk

Collection Reference Number GLC05636.05
From Archive Folder Papers related to the Amistad mutiny 
Title William S. Holabird to Henry D. Gilpin regarding a successful appeal made in the Amistad case
Date 4 May 1840
Author Holabird, William S. (1794-1855)  
Recipient Gilpin, Henry D.  
Document Type Correspondence
Content Description Holabird, United States District Attorney of Connecticut, writes to Gilpin, Attorney General. Relates that the Amistad case did not spend much time at the circuit court level, because "the counsel for the negroes [interposed?] a plea in abatement of the appeal from the decree of the district court, they contended that the U. S. had no interest in the matter, & could not appeal, that by the Treaty with Spain our courts were open to the claimants of the property, or to the representatives of the Spanish Government, that they should appear in person, & not through our Govt. upon this question the judge decided that the appeal was well taken, & at the same time, (without any further hearing) he pro forma affirmed the decree of the district Court, suggesting that it would be a waste of time to go into a trial here, as the parties & especially the Spanish Govt would not be satisfied short of the decision of the highest tribunal... the case has been conducted by the course of the abolitionists from the commencement with a view to political capital, on that account I did not regret that the judge should take the course he did..."
Subjects Amistad  African American History  Slavery  Slave Trade  Slave Rebellion  Africa  Mutiny  Maritime  Law  President  Global History and Civics  Foreign Affairs  Prisoner  Judiciary  Politics  Abolition  Treaty  
People Holabird, William S. (1794-1855)  Gilpin, Henry Dilworth (1801-1860)  Thompson, Smith (1768-1843)  
Place written Winchester, [?]
Theme Law; African Americans; Slavery & Abolition; Naval & Maritime; Merchants & Commerce; Government & Politics; Foreign Affairs
Sub-collection The Gilder Lehrman Collection, 1493-1859
Additional Information Holabird served as U.S. attorney for the District of Connecticut 1834-1841. Judges Smith Thompson and Andrew Thompson Judson presided over several levels of court proceedings of the Amistad trial.
Copyright The Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History
Module Settlement, Commerce, Revolution and Reform: 1493-1859